A 10-Year Experience with Universal Health Insurance in Taiwan: Measuring Changes in Health and Health DisparityA 10-Year Experience with Universal Health Insurance in Taiwan

Chi Pang Wen; Shan Pou Tsai; Wen-Shen Isabella Chung

doi:10.7326/0003-4819-148-4-200802190-00004

Articles |19 February 2008

A 10-Year Experience with Universal Health Insurance in Taiwan: Measuring Changes in Health and Health Disparity Free

Chi Pang Wen, MD, DrPH; Shan Pou Tsai, PhD; Wen-Shen Isabella Chung, MSc

Article, Author, and Disclosure Information

Abstract

Background:

Universal national health insurance, financed jointly by payroll taxes, subsidies, and individual premiums, commenced in Taiwan in 1995. Coverage expanded from 57% of the population (before the introduction of national health insurance) to 98%.

Objective:

To assess the role of national health insurance in improving life expectancy and reducing health disparities in Taiwan.

Design:

A before-and-after comparison of the decade before the introduction of national health insurance (1982–1984 to 1992–1994) with the decade after (1992–1994 to 2002–2004).

Setting:

Taiwan.

Patients:

All townships (n = 358) in Taiwan were ranked according to overall mortality rates before the introduction of national health insurance and then ranked into 10 health class groups in descending order of health (groups 1 [healthiest] to 10 [least healthy]).

Measurements:

Health improvement (change in life expectancy after the introduction of national health insurance) and health disparity (reduction in the difference in life expectancy between the highest- and lowest-ranked health class groups).

Results:

After the introduction of national health insurance, life expectancy increased more in health class groups that had higher mortality rates before the introduction of national health insurance and health disparity narrowed, reversing an earlier trend toward widening disparity. The major contributors to the reduction in disparity were relatively larger reductions in death from cardiovascular diseases, ill-defined conditions, infectious diseases, and accidents in the lower-ranked health class groups. However, death from cancer increased more in the lower-ranked health class groups. Utilization of medical services increased, whereas cost remained at 5% to 6% of the gross domestic product. The per capita average annual number of visits to the physician's office was 14.

Limitation:

The interpretation of comparisons before and after the introduction of national health insurance assumes that the changes were entirely due to the effect of national health insurance rather than secular trends.

Conclusion:

Life expectancy after the introduction of national health insurance improved more for lower-ranked health classes, resulting in narrowed health disparity. The magnitude of the reduced disparity was small compared with the size of the remaining gaps. Relying on universal insurance alone to eliminate health disparity does not seem realistic. To further reduce health disparity, universal insurance programs should incorporate primary prevention, focusing on lifestyle risk reductions.

Editors’ Notes

Context

The effects of implementing universal national health insurance are largely unknown.

Contribution

Taiwan imiplemented national health insurance in 1995. In the decade before national insurance, differences in life expectancy between the healthiest and least healthy regions were increasing. Afterward, they decreased, but the gaps in life expectancy between the healthiest and least healthy regions remained large. Utilization and expenditures on health care increased, whereas the percentage of gross domestic product spent on health care remained at 5% to 6%.

Caution

The authors could not prove that universal national health insurance alone reduced health disparities.

Implication

Universal national health insurance may reduce health disparities, but only by a small amount.

—The Editors

Taiwan's national health insurance has attracted worldwide attention (1–6) because of stable costs (as a proportion of gross national product) and short waiting times (7, 8). National health expenditure increased modestly from 5.1% of gross national product before the introduction of national health insurance to 6.2% 10 years later (9), which is in sharp contrast with the United States (16% of gross national product) (10). People worldwide have been demanding universal health insurance (11, 12). It has broad political and social appeal. For some, it is an issue of societal equity; for others, it offers the promise of better health (13). The lack of insurance has been associated with increased morbidity and mortality (14–16). Taiwan implemented national health insurance in 1995, which provided a rare opportunity for a natural experiment: to see whether universal insurance would improve health or reduce disparity—a twin outcome expected by the public.

National health insurance was incorporated into the existing free market system in Taiwan and offered free choice of providers to consumers and free choice of practice methods for providers under a single governmental payer. National health insurance extended existing insurance coverage (provided primarily by large employers) from 57% of the population to everyone, providing insurance to children, the elderly, and nonworking adults (17). Copayments are required: roughly 10% for inpatient and 20% for outpatient (18). These copayments, as well as income-based individual premiums, are waived for the very poor, veterans, and natives of the region. Encouraged by the ease of access, an average person made 14 visits to physicians in 2004, which is nearly 4 times the U.S. average (19). Office visits accounted for nearly two thirds of national health insurance expenditure, compared with one third in the United States (19). Office visits averaged 4 prescriptions per visit. Although Taiwan has had a culture of relying on physician visits and medications to get well, utilization increased substantially after national health insurance was introduced, particularly by elderly and poor persons.

At the start of national health insurance, the public expected that health would improve and health disparities would decline. This study aims to test this assumption based on the first 10 years of national health insurance.

Methods

Study Overview

We divided the country into 10 health class groups according to the rank-ordering of the mortality rates of 358 individual townships before the introduction of national health insurance. We measured the change in health in each of the 10 groups during the 10 years (1995 to 2004) after national health insurance was introduced compared with the previous 10 years to see whether differences in health between the highest- and lowest-ranked health class groups narrowed after national health insurance. Life expectancy was used to measure health because it is inversely correlated with overall death (20), and higher-ranked health class groups were considered healthier than lower-ranked groups.

Study Population

With the entire Taiwanese population as the reference, we calculated standardized mortality ratios for all-cause mortality in 1992–1994 for each of the 358 townships in Taiwan. We then rank-ordered the townships by standardized mortality ratios and grouped them in descending order into 10 health class groups, each with a population of approximately 2 million. The townships in health class group 1 (with the best health) had standardized mortality ratios ranging from 0.57 to 0.77, whereas those in group 10 (with the worst heath) had standardized mortality ratios of 1.17 to 3.19 (Appendix Table 1).

Appendix Table 1. Population, Number of Townships, and Range of Standardized Mortality Ratios for the 10 Health Class Groups

Data Sources

The basic data in this study are the standardized mortality ratios and life expectancy in each health class group. The data sources are the official records of the population by township, age, and sex from the Ministry of the Interior. The registered deaths, including causes of death, came from computerized files assembled by the Department of Health. Taiwan used the same method to count population and register deaths during the study period. We obtained information on health care utilization and expenditure from the official publications of the Department of Health (9) and the Bureau of National Health Insurance (17).

Outcomes

The change after introduction of national health insurance was the difference in life expectancy in each of the 10 health class groups at the beginning and end of the periods before (between 1982–1984 and 1992–1994) and after (between 1992–1994 and 2002–2004) the introduction of national health insurance. “Change before the introduction of national health insurance” is the term for the change during the period before national health insurance was implemented (between 1982–1984 and 1992–1994). “Disparity” is the difference in life expectancy between health class group 1 and each of the remaining 9 health class groups.

We compared changes in life expectancy in the periods before and after the introduction of national health insurance. The following example illustrates our calculation. The life expectancies at birth for men in health class group 2 in 1982–1984, 1992–1994, and 2002–2004 were 71.87, 74.68, and 76.65 years, respectively (Table 1). The difference (−0.84 years) was the improvement in life expectancies after the introduction of national health insurance (74.68 years to 76.65 years) minus the improvement before the introduction of national health insurance (71.87 years to 74.68 years).

Table 1. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity*

We also measured changes in health disparities before and after the introduction of national health insurance. Disparity reduction for each health class group was the difference in disparity between the period before (disparity in 1992–1994) and that after (disparity in 2002–2004) the introduction of national health insurance. To calculate the reduction in disparity for men in health class group 2, we used the life expectancies at birth for men in health class group 2 (74.68 and 76.65 years) in 1992–1994 and 2002–2004, respectively, and the life expectancies for health class group 1 (77.63 and 79.62 years, respectively) (Table 1). The change in disparity (−0.02 years) was the disparity (the difference in life expectancy between health class groups 1 and 2) at the end of the period before the introduction of national health insurance (77.63 years to 74.68 years) minus the difference after the introduction of national health insurance (79.62 years to 76.65 years).

Statistical Analysis

We used the Chiang life-table method to calculate and compare life expectancy (21). To examine the contribution of causes of deaths to life expectancy change before and after the introduction of national health insurance, we used a modified cause–deletion life-table method (22, 23). This method assumes independence for each cause of death and calculates the contributions of a cause of death to a change in overall life expectancy by incorporating the change in mortality rates for 1 particular cause at a time between 2 periods. For example, to estimate the contribution of cancer to the difference in life expectancy between 2 periods (1982–1984 and 1992–1994), we first obtained the age-specific mortality rates from cancer in 1982–1984. We then added the age-specific change in deaths from cancer between the 2 periods to the age-specific overall mortality rate in 1982–1984 and calculated life expectancy accordingly. The difference between this life expectancy and overall life expectancy in 1982–1984 was the contribution of cancer to life expectancy. We used a customized FORTRAN program to calculate cause-specific life expectancies. Other investigators have used this method (23–26), which is commonly referred to as “a decomposition of life expectancy by causes” (27–31). We used linear regression to test whether changes in life expectancy between the periods before and after the introduction of national health insurance, increased or decreased linearly by health class group.

Additional Analysis

We also did several analyses in which we pooled the original 10 health class group categories into 3 broader health class groups: high (groups 1 to 3), medium (groups 4 to 7), and low (groups 8 to 10). We minimized the effect of the decrease in accidental death rates at younger ages after the introduction of national health insurance by calculating life expectancies at age 45 years in the high, medium, and low health class groups.

Role of the Funding Source

Investigators received no outside funding.

Results

Improvement in Life Expectancy at Birth after National Health Insurance

Life expectancy in all 10 health class groups substantially improved both before and after the introduction of national health insurance (Table 1 and Appendix Figure). For Taiwan as a whole, the 2.39-year gain in life expectancy for men during the period after the introduction of national health insurance (from 71.83 years in 1992–1994 to 74.22 years in 2002–2004) was larger than the 2.27-year gain during the period before the introduction of national health insurance (from 69.56 years in 1982–1984 to 71.83 years in 1992–1994.) This overall 0.12-year (95% CI, −0.13 to 0.37 year) gain in men after the introduction of national health insurance did not differ statistically from no change. Similarly, the overall 0.05-year (CI, −0.22 to 0.32 year) gain in women did not differ statistically from no change.

Appendix Figure.

Secular trends of life expectancy at birth for the 10 health class groups (HCGs), 1982–1984 to 2002–2004.

Although the rate of gain in life expectancy did not change in the country as a whole after national health insurance, life expectancy increased faster in lower health class groups than in higher health class groups. For the bottom 3 to 4 health class groups (groups 7 to 10), the rate of gain in life expectancy was higher during the period after the introduction of national health insurance than during the period before. In addition, the rate of gain in the top 4 health class groups (groups 1 to 4) slowed considerably (Table 1 and Figure 1). For example, in health class group 8, the 2.40-year gain during the period after the introduction of national health insurance in men was greater than the 1.66-year gain during the period before the introduction of national health insurance. Figure 2 shows gains in life expectancy before and after the introduction of national health insurance. The change in life expectancy after the introduction of national health insurance increased linearly, with an increase in health class group mortality rates (groups 1 to 10) (P <0.001 for men, P = 0.002 for women [test for linear trend]). The patterns remained the same after exclusion of health class groups 1 and 10.

Figure 1.

Gain in life expectancy during the period before (1982–1984 to 1992–1994) and after (1992–1994 to 2002–2004) the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

*Increase in life expectancy during the period before NHI (from 1982–1984 to 1992–1994). †Increase in life expectancy during the period after NHI (from 1992–1994 to 2002–2004).

Figure 2.

Difference between changes in life expectancy at birth before and after the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

Pre-NHI was 1982–1984 to 1992–1994, and post-NHI was 1992–1994 to 2002–2004. Error bars represent 95% CIs.

Reduction in Disparities

The gap in life expectancy in men in health class group 1 (the healthiest) and health class group 10 (the least healthy) was 8.37 years in 1982–1984. The gap increased to 10.65 years in 1992–1994 but decreased to 10.03 years in 2002–2004 (Figure 3). This 0.62-year reduction during the period after national health insurance constituted 6% of the existing gap (10.03 years). This pattern of first widening and then narrowing before and after national health insurance was also observed for the gaps between health class group 1 versus the remaining health class groups, except for health class groups 2 and 4. A similar pattern was also seen for women. The size of reduction in disparity during the period after national health insurance was larger for women than for men (Table 1 and Figure 3).

Figure 3.

Gaps in life expectancy for health class groups 2 to 10 versus health class group 1.

Additional Analysis

The patterns of the effect of national health insurance (faster gain in life expectancy and greater reduction in disparity in the least healthy health class groups) remained the same when we formed 3 broad health class groups (Table 2) from the 10 health class groups shown in Table 1. Calculated through use of data on life expectancy at birth, changes in life expectancy after the introduction of national health insurance were substantially greater than those before the introduction of national health insurance for the low health class groups (groups 8 to 10) for both men and women, but the gain in life expectancy slowed for the high health class groups (groups 1 to 3). At age 45 years, the same pattern persisted.

Table 2. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth and at Age 45 Years before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity for 3 Broad Health Classes (High, Medium, and Low)*

Table 2. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth and at Age 45 Years before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity for 3 Broad Health Classes (High, Medium, and Low)*

Similarly, the disparity reduced substantially for both sexes in groups 8 to 10. The gap for groups 4 to 7 also reduced substantially for women. Men had a much smaller reduction in disparities when we calculated life expectancy among those who survived to age 45 years, presumably because injury deaths, which are more common in younger men, contributed substantially to disparity reduction.

Cause-Specific Contribution to Change in Life Expectancy

We evaluated the net change in death attributable to various causes of death in the high, medium, and low health class groups after the introduction of national health insurance (Figure 4; detailed data in Appendix Tables 2 and 3). The gain from reduced deaths because of a decline in cardiovascular disease was smaller for health class groups 1 to 3 after the introduction of national health insurance but increased for health class groups 8 to 10. Other causes of death that showed similar patterns were accidental deaths and ill-defined conditions. On the other hand, death from cancer increased in all 3 groups but increased more for the lowest-ranked health class groups and offset some of the gains from other causes. The patterns were similar for women but with a larger positive contribution from cardiovascular diseases and smaller negative contribution from cancer deaths.

Figure 4.

Cause-specific contribution to gain in life expectancy during the period before and after the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

HCG = health class group. Results are based on a modified cause–deletion life-table method, which assumes independence for each cause of death. Not all possible causes of death are included. Bars extending below the horizontal axis indicate that deaths from those causes contributed to reduced life expectancy, whereas bars extending above the horizontal axis contributed to improved life expectancy.

Appendix Table 2. Decomposition of Gap during the Period before the Introduction of National Health Insurance, 1982–1984 to 1992–1994

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Socioeconomic and Lifestyle Differences between the Healthiest and Unhealthiest Groups

To examine why health class group 10 continued to have poorer health, we compared the socioeconomic and lifestyle factors in health class groups 1 and 10 (Table 3). The per capita income for residents in health class group 10 ($8085) was about half that of health class group 1 ($15 679). The lifestyle risk factors, including smoking (51% vs. 36%), betel quid chewing (33% vs. 6%), and obesity (9% vs. 5%), were more prevalent among male residents in health class group 10 than among their counterparts in health class group 1. They also consumed 4 times as much alcohol and had 4 times higher mortality rates from accidental injuries. In addition, health class group 10 used more health care services than health class group 1, with 31% more office visits (14.0 vs. 10.7 visits per person) and 9% more hospital admissions (14.2 vs. 13.0 hospital admissions per 100 persons).

Table 3. Comparison of Selected Statistics between Health Class Groups 1 and 10 in 2004

National Health Insurance: Utilization and Expenditures

Averaging 14.2 visits in 2004, Taiwanese people made 12.6 visits to Western medicine facilities and 1.6 visits to traditional Chinese or herbal medicine practitioners, an independent practice from Western medicine. Women made 21% more visits than men, and elderly persons made more than twice the average number of visits (Appendix Tables 4 and 5). National health insurance also covers dental services. Outpatient services accounted for nearly two thirds (60%) of national health insurance expenditure. Each visit generated an average of 4.1 prescriptions. The length of hospital stay increased slightly from 9.4 days to 9.7 days, and inpatient admission rates increased by 35%, from 10.1 to 13.6 admissions per 100 persons, during the 10-year period. Admission rates after the introduction of national health insurance nearly tripled for those who were uninsured before the introduction of national health insurance and remained stable among those who were insured before the introduction of national health insurance (1–3).

Appendix Table 4. Outpatient and Inpatient Medical Care Utilization and Expenditure under National Health Insurance in Taiwan, 1995 to 2004

Appendix Table 5. Number and Expenditure of Physician Visits per Person in 2004, by Age

With an average income of $15 170 in 2004, the average Taiwanese person spent $926 on health care, an increase from $548 the year before the introduction of national health insurance (Table 4). Health care expenditures comprised 5.1% of gross national product in 1994 and 6.2% in 2004. The sources of national health insurance revenues were individual premiums (38%), employer contributions (35%), and government subsidies (26%). Expenditures under national health insurance were 57% of national health expenditure in 1995 and 53% in 2005.

Table 4. National Health Care Expenditures in Taiwan

Discussion

This study shows that people in poorer health improved more than people in good health after the introduction of national health insurance, narrowing the disparity and reversing an earlier widening trend. However, the amount of narrowing was small (for example, 0.62 year or 6% for men in health class group 10) compared with the size of the existing gap (10.03 years). Expecting national health insurance to eliminate the remaining gap (94%) is not realistic.

When universal health insurance was first introduced in Taiwan, public health and medical professionals assumed that national health insurance would achieve its twin goals of accelerating health improvement and reducing health disparity (1, 4). The 10-year experience showed that the rate of health improvement increased, but only in the lower health classes, and health disparity decreased, but not by very much. Although the lowest health class group used more medical services and had larger gains in life expectancy—seemingly an accomplishment of national health insurance—we need to be cautious about concluding that national health insurance caused these changes. For example, it is difficult to link changes in mortality rate from specific causes to purported effects of national health insurance, such as improving access and quality of care. Death from ill-defined conditions, infectious diseases, and cardiovascular diseases decreased, as expected. It is reassuring that the lower-ranked health class groups had greater improvement in cardiovascular diseases (Figure 4), which is the major contributor to the reduction in disparity. However, death from cancer and diabetes increased. In fact, national health insurance was not designed to reduce disease incidence, such as cancer, and people in the lower-ranked health class group had more cancer or diabetes risk factors. Furthermore, a reduction in motor vehicle accidents was an important contributor to the disparity reduction. The implementation of the helmet law for motorcyclists in 1997 (33, 34) has primarily affected people in the lower socioeconomic groups (35).

Health care expenditure grew at a pace similar to the growth of the economy, despite a substantial increase in utilization of medical services (8). Cost containment (spending at a rate equivalent to one seventh of that of the United States), while keeping abreast of state-of-the-art technology, has been acclaimed as a remarkable achievement for Taiwan (7), especially as life expectancy in Taiwan is similar to the United States (19). Access to health care expanded without causing long waiting times.

Frequent office visits, averaging 14 visits a year, are a hallmark of the period after the introduction of national health insurance in Taiwan. Expenditures for outpatient care exceed inpatient care expenditures by a 2:1 ratio. The increase in office visits may be a reflection of the Taiwanese public's perception of how to stay well, by relying more on office visits and medicines than on pursuing a healthier lifestyle. McKeown (36) reported the limited contribution of “medical care” to population health a quarter century ago. His unorthodox concept has received increasing support over the ensuing years (37–40), and the experience in this study and in a recent elderly cohort (6) after national health insurance was implemented adds additional evidence. Ensuring medical care for all, through adopting universal insurance, remains an unrealized goal for countries like the United States. However, traditional medical care per se has only a limited effect on life expectancy, perhaps 10% to 15%, when other determinants of a developed nation's health are taken into account (41). Compared with lifestyle factors (42), medical care has a limited effect on disease incidence, especially for cancer.

The disparity gap decreased more for women (13%) than for men (6%) after the introduction of national health insurance. This difference could be due to sex difference in lifestyle risk factors. Two risk behaviors among men in Taiwan, smoking and betel quid chewing, remained high after the introduction of national health insurance. Every second middle-aged man is a smoker (43) and every fourth is a chewer (44, 45). The rates of smoking and chewing remained much higher in health class group 10 than in health class group 1, which could account for the large increases in lung and oral cancer in the lower socioeconomic groups and the relatively small reduction in health disparities after national health insurance (46, 47). National health insurance did not provide incentives to stop smoking or chewing. We hope that Taiwan adopts policies to promote disease prevention as a key strategy to reduce health disparities (48). We believe that a government policy of universal health insurance has the distinct advantage of being able to devote resources to prevention and other long-term goals without pressure to respond to short-term financial results.

Our study has important limitations. First, it used the methods of observational research, which means that we cannot be certain that changes after the introduction of national health insurance were due to national health insurance. Second, more than half (57%) of the population had medical insurance at the start of national health insurance, which may have diluted the effect of national health insurance, although those who gained insurance were mainly the elderly and the vulnerable, many of whom were in the least healthy health class groups. Third, in some instances, we did not have similar data before and after the introduction of national health insurance to adjust for the possible effects of unrelated social changes on life expectancy. For example, social changes, such as the helmet law for mortorcyclists, probably improved life expectancy. Fourth, quality of care after the introduction of national health insurance varied across health class groups: Higher-ranked health class groups were primarily found in urban areas, which have superior health care facilities (49). Fifth, life expectancy is an imperfect health indicator. It is widely used and easily understood (20) but not sufficiently sensitive to the effect of specific causes of deaths, forcing us to use analytic methods that assume that causes of death are independent of one another. In addition, income, education, and the environment all contribute to life expectancy, and the contribution of access to health care in Taiwan to improvements in life expectancy is unknown. Therefore, using life expectancy as a summary measure may miss effects of improved access to care due to national health insurance. Sixth, the value of national health insurance goes far beyond prolongation of life, which is the only indicator of health in this study. It can relieve pain and suffering, improve quality of life, provide emotional security, and increase human dignity. Finally, a 10-year period may be too brief to measure the full effect of national health insurance. However, this shortcoming is partially offset by comparing the period after the introduction of national health insurance with an additional 10 years before its introduction.

In conclusion, health improved countrywide after the introduction of national health insurance in Taiwan, but the change was small when superimposed on a rising secular trend. National health insurance had strong support from the public (50), and utilization of health services increased after the introduction of national health insurance. Life expectancy increased more rapidly in the lower-ranked health class groups than in the higher ones, and therefore narrowed the gaps in disparity, albeit by a small proportion of the entire gap. The groups with poorer health had a relatively greater reduction in death from cardiovascular diseases, followed by ill-defined conditions, infectious diseases, and accident trends that were somewhat offset by increased cancer deaths as a result of a higher prevalence of lifestyle-related risk factors. To further reduce health disparity, universal insurance programs should incorporate primary prevention, focusing on lifestyle risk reductions.

References

Chiang
TL
Taiwan's 1995 health care reform.
Health Policy
1997
39
225
39
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Cheng
SH
Chiang
TL
The effect of universal health insurance on health care utilization in Taiwan. Results from a natural experiment.
JAMA
1997
278
89
93
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Cheng
SH
Chiang
TL
Disparity of medical care utilization among different health insurance schemes in Taiwan.
Soc Sci Med
1998
47
613
20
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Cheng
TM
Taiwan's new national health insurance program: genesis and experience so far.
Health Aff (Millwood)
2003
22
61
76
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Peabody
JW
Yu
JC
Wang
YR
Bickel
SR
Health system reform in the Republic of China. Formulating policy in a market-based health system.
JAMA
1995
273
777
81
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Chen
L
Yip
W
Chang
MC
Lin
HS
Lee
SD
Chiu
YL
et al
The effects of Taiwan's National Health Insurance on access and health status of the elderly.
Health Econ
2007
16
223
42
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Project HOPE
Universal coverage in Taiwan.
Health Aff (Millwood)
2003
22
60
.
PubMed
Lu
JF
Hsiao
WC
Does universal health insurance make health care unaffordable? Lessons from Taiwan.
Health Aff (Millwood)
2003
22
77
88
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
National Health Expenditure, 2004. Taipeienglish/4/2004NHE.pdf: Department of Health; 2005. Accessed at www.doh.gov.tw/statistic/ on 3 June 2007.
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Highlights, 2006. Accessed at www.cms.hhs.gov/NationalHealthExpendData/downloads/highlights.pdf on 12 June 2007.
Emanuel
EJ
Fuchs
VR
Health care vouchers—a proposal for universal coverage.
N Engl J Med
2005
352
1255
60
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Blank
RH
Burau
V
Comparative Health Policy.
New York
Palgrave Macmillan
2004
Chua KP. The Case for Universal Health Care. Reston, VA: American Medical Student Association. Accessed at www.amsa.org/uhc/CaseForUHC.pdf on 12 June 2007.
Baker
DW
Sudano
JJ
Albert
JM
Borawski
EA
Dor
A
Lack of health insurance and decline in overall health in late middle age.
N Engl J Med
2001
345
1106
12
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Ayanian
JZ
Weissman
JS
Schneider
EC
Ginsburg
JA
Zaslavsky
AM
Unmet health needs of uninsured adults in the United States.
JAMA
2000
284
2061
9
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Franks
P
Clancy
CM
Gold
MR
Health insurance and mortality. Evidence from a national cohort.
JAMA
1993
270
737
41
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
National Health Insurance Annual Statistical Report 1995-2004.
Taipei, Taiwan
Bureau of National Health Insurance
1996-2005
National Health Insurance Act. Article 36. Taipei: R.O.C; Second Amendment 15 July 1999.
National Center for Health Statistics
Health, United States, 2005 with Chartbook on Trends in the Health of Americans.
Hyattsville, MD
National Center for Health Statistics
2005
Tsai
SP
Hardy
RJ
Wen
CP
The standardized mortality ratio and life expectancy.
Am J Epidemiol
1992
135
824
31
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Chiang
CL
The Life Table and Its Applications.
Malabar, India
R.E. Krieger
1984
Tsai
SP
Lee
ES
Hardy
RJ
The effect of a reduction in leading causes of death: potential gains in life expectancy.
Am J Public Health
1978
68
966
71
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Tsai
SP
Lee
ES
Kautz
JA
Changes in life expectancy in the United States due to declines in mortality, 1968-1975.
Am J Epidemiol
1982
116
376
84
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Wen
CP
Tsai
SP
Shih
YT
Chung
WS
Bridging the gap in life expectancy of the aborigines in Taiwan.
Int J Epidemiol
2004
33
320
7
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Lai
D
Hardy
RJ
An update on the impact of HIV/AIDS on life expectancy in the United States.
AIDS
2004
18
1732
4
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Cutler
DM
Rosen
AB
Vijan
S
The value of medical spending in the United States, 1960-2000.
N Engl J Med
2006
355
920
7
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Arriaga
EE
Measuring and explaining the change in life expectancies.
Demography
1984
21
83
96
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Retherford
RD
Tobacco smoking and the sex mortality differential.
Demography
1972
9
203
16
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Pollard
JH
The expectation of life and its relationship to mortality.
J Inst Actuaries
1982
109
225
40
CrossRef
Pollard
JH
On the decomposition of changes in expectation of life and differentials in life expectancy.
Demography
1988
25
265
76
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Lopez
AD
Ruzicka
LT
Studies in Australian Mortality.
Hobart, Tasmania
University of Tasmania
1977
Chang
HY
Pan
WH
Yeh
WT
Tsai
KS
Hyperuricemia and gout in Taiwan: results from the Nutritional and Health Survey in Taiwan (1993–96).
J Rheumatol
2001
28
1640
6
PubMed
PubMed
Tsai
MC
Hemenway
D
Effect of the mandatory helmet law in Taiwan.
Inj Prev
1999
5
290
1
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Keng
SH
Helmet use and motorcycle fatalities in Taiwan.
Accid Anal Prev
2005
37
349
55
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Number of Registered Motor Vehicles in Taiwan-Fuchien Area. Monthly Statistics of Transportation and Communication: Table 4-5. Taipei, Taiwan: Department of Statistics, Ministry of Transportation and Communications ROC; 2007. Accessed at www.motc.gov.tw/hypage.cgi?HYPAGE=stat01.asp on 3 June 2007.
McKeown
T
The Role of Medicine: Dream, Mirage, or Nemesis?
London
Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust
1976
Unal
B
Critchley
JA
Fidan
D
Capewell
S
Life-years gained from modern cardiological treatments and population risk factor changes in England and Wales, 1981-2000.
Am J Public Health
2005
95
103
8
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Schroeder
SA
Shattuck Lecture. We can do better—improving the health of the American people.
N Engl J Med
2007
357
1221
8
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Lamm
RD
Blank
RH
Condition Critical: A New Moral Vision for Health Care (Speaker's Corner Books).
Golden, CO
Fulcrum Publishing
2007
Bunker
JP
The role of medical care in contributing to health improvements within societies.
Int J Epidemiol
2001
30
1260
3
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Isaacs
SL
Schroeder
SA
Class - the ignored determinant of the nation's health.
N Engl J Med
2004
351
1137
42
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Mokdad
AH
Marks
JS
Stroup
DF
Gerberding
JL
Actual causes of death in the United States, 2000.
JAMA
2004
291
1238
45
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Wen
CP
Levy
DT
Cheng
TY
Hsu
CC
Tsai
SP
Smoking behaviour in Taiwan, 2001.
Tob Control
2005
14
i51
5
CrossRef

PubMed
Wen
CP
Tsai
SP
Cheng
TY
et al
Uncovering the relation between betel quid chewing and cigarette smoking in Taiwan.
Tob Control
2005
14
i16
22
CrossRef

PubMed
Chang
WC
Hsiao
CF
Chang
HY
Lan
TY
Hsiung
CA
Shih
YT
et al
Betel nut chewing and other risk factors associated with obesity among Taiwanese male adults.
Int J Obes (Lond)
2006
30
359
63
PubMed
CrossRef

PubMed
Department of Health
Cancer Registry Annual Report, 1995.
Taipei, Taiwan
Department of Health
1998
Department of Health
Cancer Registry Annual Report, 2002.
Taipei, Taiwan
Department of Health
2005
Cheng
TY
Wen
CP
Tsai
SP
Chung
WSI
Hsu
CC
Reducing health disparity in Taiwan: quantifying the role of smoking.
Tob Control
2005
14
i23
7
CrossRef

PubMed
Bureau of National Health Insurance
National Health Insurance Annual Statistical Report, 2004.
Taipei, Taiwan
Bureau of National Health Insurance
2005
Bureau of National Health Insurance. Survey for NHI Satisfaction (in Chinese). Accessed at www.nhi.gov.tw/webdata/webdata.asp?menu=6&menu_id=168&webdata_id=1450&IsPrint=1 on 7 September 2007.

Appendix Figure.

Secular trends of life expectancy at birth for the 10 health class groups (HCGs), 1982–1984 to 2002–2004.

Figure 1.

Gain in life expectancy during the period before (1982–1984 to 1992–1994) and after (1992–1994 to 2002–2004) the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

*Increase in life expectancy during the period before NHI (from 1982–1984 to 1992–1994). †Increase in life expectancy during the period after NHI (from 1992–1994 to 2002–2004).

Figure 2.

Difference between changes in life expectancy at birth before and after the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

Pre-NHI was 1982–1984 to 1992–1994, and post-NHI was 1992–1994 to 2002–2004. Error bars represent 95% CIs.

Figure 3.

Gaps in life expectancy for health class groups 2 to 10 versus health class group 1.

Figure 4.

Cause-specific contribution to gain in life expectancy during the period before and after the introduction of national health insurance (NHI).

Appendix Table 1. Population, Number of Townships, and Range of Standardized Mortality Ratios for the 10 Health Class Groups

Table 1. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity*

Table 2. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth and at Age 45 Years before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity for 3 Broad Health Classes (High, Medium, and Low)*

Appendix Table 2. Decomposition of Gap during the Period before the Introduction of National Health Insurance, 1982–1984 to 1992–1994

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Table 3. Comparison of Selected Statistics between Health Class Groups 1 and 10 in 2004

Appendix Table 4. Outpatient and Inpatient Medical Care Utilization and Expenditure under National Health Insurance in Taiwan, 1995 to 2004

Appendix Table 5. Number and Expenditure of Physician Visits per Person in 2004, by Age

Table 4. National Health Care Expenditures in Taiwan

Clinical Slide Sets

Terms of Use

The In the Clinic® slide sets are owned and copyrighted by the American College of Physicians (ACP). All text, graphics, trademarks, and other intellectual property incorporated into the slide sets remain the sole and exclusive property of the ACP. The slide sets may be used only by the person who downloads or purchases them and only for the purpose of presenting them during not-for-profit educational activities. Users may incorporate the entire slide set or selected individual slides into their own teaching presentations but may not alter the content of the slides in any way or remove the ACP copyright notice. Users may make print copies for use as hand-outs for the audience the user is personally addressing but may not otherwise reproduce or distribute the slides by any means or media, including but not limited to sending them as e-mail attachments, posting them on Internet or Intranet sites, publishing them in meeting proceedings, or making them available for sale or distribution in any unauthorized form, without the express written permission of the ACP. Unauthorized use of the In the Clinic slide sets will constitute copyright infringement.

This feature is available only to Registered Users

Subscribe/Learn More

PDF

Not Available

2008 American College of Physicians

Articles |19 February 2008

A 10-Year Experience with Universal Health Insurance in Taiwan: Measuring Changes in Health and Health Disparity Free

Abstract

Editors’ Notes

Context

Contribution

Caution

Implication

Methods

Study Overview

Study Population

Appendix Table 1. Population, Number of Townships, and Range of Standardized Mortality Ratios for the 10 Health Class Groups

Data Sources

Outcomes

Table 1. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity*

Statistical Analysis

Additional Analysis

Role of the Funding Source

Results

Improvement in Life Expectancy at Birth after National Health Insurance

Appendix Figure.

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Reduction in Disparities

Figure 3.

Additional Analysis

Table 2. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth and at Age 45 Years before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity for 3 Broad Health Classes (High, Medium, and Low)*

Cause-Specific Contribution to Change in Life Expectancy

Figure 4.

Appendix Table 2. Decomposition of Gap during the Period before the Introduction of National Health Insurance, 1982–1984 to 1992–1994

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Socioeconomic and Lifestyle Differences between the Healthiest and Unhealthiest Groups

Table 3. Comparison of Selected Statistics between Health Class Groups 1 and 10 in 2004

National Health Insurance: Utilization and Expenditures

Appendix Table 4. Outpatient and Inpatient Medical Care Utilization and Expenditure under National Health Insurance in Taiwan, 1995 to 2004

Appendix Table 5. Number and Expenditure of Physician Visits per Person in 2004, by Age

Table 4. National Health Care Expenditures in Taiwan

Discussion

References

Appendix Figure.

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

Appendix Table 1. Population, Number of Townships, and Range of Standardized Mortality Ratios for the 10 Health Class Groups

Table 1. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity*

Table 2. Difference between Life Expectancy at Birth and at Age 45 Years before and after the Introduction of National Health Insurance and Change in Disparity for 3 Broad Health Classes (High, Medium, and Low)*

Appendix Table 2. Decomposition of Gap during the Period before the Introduction of National Health Insurance, 1982–1984 to 1992–1994

Appendix Table 3. Decomposition of Gap during the Period after the Introduction of National Health Insurance (NHI), 1992–1994 to 2002–2004

Table 3. Comparison of Selected Statistics between Health Class Groups 1 and 10 in 2004

Appendix Table 4. Outpatient and Inpatient Medical Care Utilization and Expenditure under National Health Insurance in Taiwan, 1995 to 2004

Appendix Table 5. Number and Expenditure of Physician Visits per Person in 2004, by Age

Table 4. National Health Care Expenditures in Taiwan

Clinical Slide Sets

This feature is available only to Registered Users

0 Comments

See Also

Related Articles

Related Topics

PubMed Articles

Content

Information For

Services

Awards

Other Resources

Follow Annals On

You need a subscription to this content to use this feature.

Sign In